GIRLS
| Caitlin Collier*, FL | 2:03.32 | 2017 |
| Hannah Long*, MO | 2:04.23 | 2015 |
| Tessa Buswell, CA | 2:06.55 | 2024 |
| Sophia Bendet, TX | 2:06.65 | 2024 |
| Elena Rybek, IL | 2:06.68 | 2024 |
| Paige Stuart, MO | 2:06.98 | 2024 |
| Elyse Wilmes, MO | 2:07.37 | 2024 |
| Marlena Preigh, CO | 2:07.56 | 2018 |
| Makayla Clark, MO | 2:07.97 | 2022 |
| Abby Downin, DE | 2:08.03 | 2024 |
*competed in the professional women’s 800 race
BOYS
| Daniel Watcke, IL | 1:48.59 | 2023 |
| Patrick Hilby, IL | 1:48.81 | 2023 |
| Ethan Walther, DE | 1:49.92 | 2024 |
| Alexander Waldie, KS | 1:49.97 | 2023 |
| Brandon Miller, MO | 1:50.03 | 2018 |
| Noah Nielson, UT | 1:50.16 | 2024 |
| Carlton Orange, TN | 1:50.45 | 2015 |
| Daniel Watcke, IA | 1:50.81 | 2022 |
| Cain Evans, CA | 1:50.87 | 2024 |
| Nicolas Pizarro, DE | 1:50.90 | 2022 |