BOYS
| Simeon Birnbaum, SD | 3:57.53 | 2023 |
| Drew Griffith, PA | 3:57.72 | 2024 |
| Gary Martin*, PA | 3:57.89 | 2022 |
| Rocky Hansen, NC | 3:58.23 | 2023 |
| Tinoda Matsatsa, MD | 3:58.70 | 2023 |
| Connor Burns*, MO | 3:58.83 | 2022 |
| Jackson Heidesch, IA | 3:57.08 | 2023 |
| Reed Brown*, TX | 3:59.30 | 2017 |
| Grant Fisher*, MI | 3:59.38 | 2015 |
| Clay Shively, KS | 4:00.02 | 2024 |
| Nathan Neil, MT | 4:00.76 | 2024 |
| Tayson Echohawk, UT | 4:01.07 | 2023 |
| Clay Shively, KS | 4:01.47 | 2023 |
| Tommy Latham, GA | 4:01.74 | 2024 |
| James Partlow, MD | 4:03.21 | 2024 |
| Connor Burns, MO | 4:03.25 | 2023 |
| Steven Hergenrother, CT | 4:03.46 | 2024 |
| Andreas Dybdahl, CA | 4:03.88 | 2024 |
| Brian Dicola, PA | 4:04.14 | 2023 |
| Adam Burlison, TX | 4:04.19 | 2024 |
*competed in the professional men’s race
GIRLS
| Sadie Engelhardt*, CA | 4:28.46 | 2024 |
| Allie Zealand, VA | 4:30.38 | 2024 |
| Charlotte Bell, NC | 4:35.70 | 2024 |
| Allison Ince, IL | 4:35.96 | 2024 |
| Isabel Allori, CO | 4:37.32 | 2024 |
| Logan St. John Kletter, PA | 4:37.44 | 2024 |
| Tatum David*, IL | 4:37.79 | 2023 |
| Ellery Lincoln, OR | 4:40.75 | 2024 |
| Addison Dorenkamp, IA | 4:40.82 | 2024 |
| Charlotte Bell, NC | 4:41.33 | 2023 |
| Samantha Humphries, TX | 4:41.93 | 2023 |
| Tatum David, IL | 4:42.15 | 2022 |
| Leah Stephens, MD | 4:42.19 | 2023 |
| Natalie Cook*, TX | 4:42.33 | 2022 |
| Stella Kermes, NC | 4:42.90 | 2023 |
| Paityn Noe, IA | 4:43.37 | 2023 |
| Allison Ince, IL | 4:43.67 | 2023 |
| Abby Faith Cheeseman, TN | 4:44.59 | 2023 |
| Samantha Humphries, TX | 4:45.11 | 2022 |
| Stella Kermes, NC | 4:45.23 | 2024 |
*competed in the professional women’s race