| Jordan McNamara, Nike OTC Elite | 3:54.27 | 2014 |
| Leo Manzano, Nike | 3:55.29 | 2009 |
| Paul Ryan, Golden Coast, Adidas | 3:55.95 | 2022 |
| Ben Veatch, Under Armour Dark Sky | 3:56.04 | 2024 |
| Duncan Phillips, Unattached | 3:56.10 | 2014 |
| Jordan McNamara, Nike OTC Elite | 3:56.39 | 2016 |
| Tommy Schmitz, Speed Factory Athletics | 3:56.45 | 2014 |
| Olin Hacker, HOKA NAZ Elite | 3:56.59 | 2023 |
| Brett Meyer, Unattached | 3:56.71 | 2021 |
| Jack Anstey, Dark Sky Distance | 3:56.87 | 2022 |
| Olin Hacker, HOKA NAZ Elite | 3:56.89 | 2024 |
| Jason Clayton, Loyola University Chicago | 3:57.06 | 2024 |
| Brett Meyer, Altra Running | 3:57.06 | 2023 |
| Frezer Legesse, Under Armour | 3:57.24 | 2016 |
| Brett Meyer, Hold Fast Running | 3:57.28 | 2024 |
| Ahmed Muhumed, HOKA NAZ Elite | 3:57.32 | 2024 |
| Jon Davis, University of Illinois | 3:57.39 | 2021 |
| Cristian Soratos, Adidas | 3:57.39 | 2016 |
| Morgan McDonald, Unattached | 3:57.52 | 2017 |
| Simeon Birnbaum, Rapid City Stevens High School (SD) | 3:57.45 | 2023 |
| Caleb Webb, Unattached | 3:57.54 | 2022 |
| Bryce Richards, Unattached | 3:57.61 | 2021 |
| Caleb Webb, Unattached | 3:57.62 | 2024 |
| Nick Willis, Tracksmith | 3:57.62 | 2021 |
| Drew Griffith, Butler Senior High School (PA) | 3:57.72 | 2024 |
| Austen Dalquest, Roots Running | 3:57.77 | 2024 |
| Jordan McNamara, Nike OTC Elite | 3:57.84 | 2011 |
| Derek Scott, Team Indiana Elite | 3:57.87 | 2009 |
| Gary Martin, Archbishop Wood High School (PA) | 3:57.89 | 2022 |
| Jack Anstey, Under Armour Dark Sky | 3:57.91 | 2024 |
| Jack Gillum, Shazam Racing | 3:57.98 | 2024 |
| Julian Oakley, Unattached | 3:58.02 | 2021 |
| Andy McClary, Unattached | 3:58.14 | 2010 |
| Jack Anstey, Unattached | 3:58.17 | 2021 |
| Amos Bartelsmeyer, Unattached | 3:58.18 | 2019 |
| Rocky Hansen, Christ School (NC) | 3:58.23 | 2023 |
| Tommy Schmitz, Saucony | 3:58.40 | 2010 |
| Paul Ryan, Adidas Golden Coast Track Club | 3:58.45 | 2024 |
| Tripp Hurt, Unattached | 3:58.54 | 2018 |
| John Jefferson, Team Indiana Elite | 3:58.54 | 2011 |
| Stephen Pifer, Nike OTC Elite | 3:58.55 | 2011 |
| Rorey Hunter, Australia | 3:58.59 | 2017 |
| Sam Atkin, Unattached | 3:58.60 | 2018 |
| Josef Tessema, Unattached | 3:58.66 | 2019 |
| Tinoda Matsatsa, St. Andrews Episcopal (MD) | 3:58.70 | 2023 |
| Jordan McNamara, Nike OTC Elite | 3:58.81 | 2015 |
| Connor Burns, Southern Boone High School (MO) | 3:58.83 | 2022 |
| Nick Harris, Unattached | 3:58.88 | 2018 |
| Chris Gowell, adidas Rogue TC | 3:58.90 | 2014 |
| Tyler Pennel, Reebok ZAP Fitness | 3:58.99 | 2015 |
| Jackson Heidesch, Dowling Catholic High School (IA) | 3:59.08 | 2023 |
| Craig Miller, New Balance | 3:59.23 | 2013 |
| Jake Gillum, Unattached | 3:59.26 | 2023 |
| Reed Brown, Carroll High School (TX) | 3:59.30 | 2017 |
| Tommy Schmitz, Saucony WRRT | 3:59.36 | 2009 |
| Grant Fisher, Grand Blanc High School (MI) | 3:59.38 | 2015 |
| Daniel Clark, Unattached | 3:59.45 | 2013 |
| Derek Gutierrez, Unattached | 3:59.48 | 2018 |
| Liam Back, Unattached | 3:59.48 | 2023 |
| Pablo Solares, Bay Area Track Club | 3:59.49 | 2013 |
| Jason Clayton, Loyola Chicago | 3:59.53 | 2022 |
| Jordan Mann, Ocean State Athletic Club | 3:59.68 | 2018 |
| Olli Hoare, Unattached | 3:59.70 | 2017 |
| Craig Nowak, Pace Pirate | 3:59.72 | 2024 |
| Jack Bolas, New Balance | 3:59.75 | 2012 |
| Brett Meyer, Unattached | 3:59.77 | 2018 |
| Euan Makepeace, Big River Running | 3:59.92 | 2022 |
| Garrett Heath, Brooks Beast | 3:59.93 | 2018 |
| Adam Moore, Windsor Slough Eton & Honslow AC | 3:59.99 | 2024 |
